What Characteristics Make Someone an Ideal Supreme Court Nominee?

February 14, 2024

If you want to be a supreme court justice, you need some very specific characteristics. Having impeccable integrity, excellent legal experience, a commitment to the Constitution, and a demonstrated judicial temperament are essential. You also need to be a very good communicator, able to explain complex legal issues in plain English and to work well with others on the bench and with other stakeholders.

The most important attribute is a commitment to the constitutional system of government. The Constitution is the foundation for all federal law, and it should be followed by a judge in every case they hear.

Justices need to be impartial and independent and should not be influenced by their political party or the president that nominates them. They should also be willing to stand their ground even when they disagree with the other justices or with their colleagues on the other benches. Justices spend years in the minority, and some of them have changed the course of the law with powerful dissenting opinions.

In the past, the president’s picks for Supreme Court justices have come from a wide variety of backgrounds. They have included governors (Sandra Day O’Connor) and senators (Hugo Black, Frank Murphy, Earl Warren). There have been judges from the state and federal courts and law professors. And they have included people with some other types of jobs, such as public policy advocates and corporate executives.

Now, nearly all of the supreme court justices are sitting federal appellate judges. That trend is likely to continue for decades, because it’s the most common path to the job. Presidents once nominated people with a diverse array of backgrounds, but they have become more reliant on choosing judges from lower courts because they seem easier to confirm, Urofsky says.


Tornado Dave is the best place to learn more about severe weather and climate science. He's a veritable tornado of information, and he loves nothing more than educating others about the importance of being prepared for extreme weather events. Make sure to check in with Tornado Dave often, as he's always updating his blog with the latest news and information!
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram